• NME.COM
  • Thursday, 4 December 2008

NME News

Emo to be made illegal in Russia?

My Chemical Romance fans protest at the Daily Mail's London office

My Chemical Romance fans protest at the Daily Mail's London office

New laws planned to stop 'dangerous teen trends'

A new Russian law could make being an emo kid illegal in the eastern European country.

Legislation is currenting being formulated in Russia to heavily regulate emo websites and ban emo and goth dress style in schools and government buildings.

The new laws are apparently being driven by fears that these "dangerous teen trends" encourage depression and suicide.

The legislation was presented last month at a hearing held by the State Durma, where critics claimed that the "negative" emo culture encourages anti-social behaviour and glorifies suicide.

Emo kids were described as teenagers who wear black, have facial piercings and black hair with fringes that "cover half the face", reports The Guardian

The weekend saw mass protests by Russian emo kids.

In Krasnoyarsk, Siberia, where laws are already being implemented, protestors in a march held signs saying "A Totalitarian State Encourages Stupidity".

Dmitry Gilevich of Russian emo band MAIO stepped in backing the protests, saying: "Expressing psychological emotions is not forbidden by law."

However, emo critics remain unconvinced.

Alexander Grishunin, an adviser to bill sponsor Yevgeny Yuryev, described a ban as necessary, stating: "This is the first step in the public discourse."

The moves in Russia follow criticism of the genre in the UK earlier this year, which saw My Chemical Romance fans protesting at the offices of British newspaper The Daily Mail over their coverage which linked emo with suicide.

Comments (45)

Add a comment

krazybabe 

Jul 23, 2008

How can you possibly make a style of dressing/accesorising illegal? I think the focus needs to be moved away from emos at the end of the day all they are harming is themselves whereas other social groupings such as chavs for instance are actually causing alot of trouble within society-these are the people who think its acceptable to carry knife's and guns go and stab/shoot some inoccent member of the public.

jlong5000 

Jul 23, 2008

well, pack you bags dear (talking to my hypothetical girlfriend) we're moving to russia.

Richieboon 

Jul 23, 2008

Russia has done a lot wrong over the years. But this is legendary!!. Britain should do the same. There would be a lot less whiney moaning people around complaining about all there "problems".

mellow 

Jul 24, 2008

gud idea, should do the same here!might see more kids smile

muhammed legend 

Jul 24, 2008

In fairness i dont like Emo's i dont like their style, personalitys or the majority of their music, however this is ridiculous how can you even consider banning a genre its like something out of a really far fetched film. Also if anything by giving Emo this attention its only going to increase the 'problem'. Well done Russia for your giant leap into dictatorship.

[Sm]Emily 

Jul 24, 2008

"chavs for instance are actually causing alot of trouble within society"how is saying that any worse than stopping people from dressing as "emos" narrow-mindedess is not something to be proud of.Social stereotypng is hardly big news is it but BANNING a style of dress is just ridculous and let's be honest being emo really dosen't lead to anything does it. Contary to popular opinion it is perfectly possible to be depressed and not emo OR even emo and not depressed. Would you ever believe it?

cisumdam 

Jul 24, 2008

emo what a load of old poo, boys wearing make up and crying because their hair wont do that flicky thing.all hail russia!

danncc1701d 

Jul 24, 2008

Yeah, good on you Russia! let's ban those stupid emos with their funny haircuts LOL! Why stop there though? if you're going to ban one demographic, why not ban homosexuality as well?how about religious freedom, let's ban that as well. And those pesky Jews, let's get rid of them too.It's a slippery slope, the facetious tone of some of the posts here disgusts me.

gillhaus 

Jul 24, 2008

Ah yes, the 'State Durma'... It's the Duma you hopeless retards.

colonelmatt 

Jul 24, 2008

This is very much a case of"You are free to do as we tell you..."How far are they going with this ban? If I was in Russia would I be allowed to listen to Cap'n Jazz??? Let's face it they kicked this whole genre/scene off 20 years ago!You can just imagine Russian delegates slowly working their way through banning the different groups of people who annoy them on their way to work

M1keyBoi 

Jul 24, 2008

thats hilarious.

Drum4urLife 

Jul 24, 2008

So hang on, Russia is going to make being an emo illegal?What are the police in Russia going to do? Arrest anyone that looks a bit like an emo and charge them with intent to commit suicide? This is absolutely ridiculous and is clearly going to be impossible for the authorities to control. There are already cases all over the world of innocent people being arrested because they look like a terrorist... This is going to cause similar problems with peoples basic rights. Freedom of expression is key to how the world works. This is the first step to getting everyone in line with what a few people deem as acceptable...

jordypark 

Jul 25, 2008

Ah..the Russians taking a step back into Communism, banning the basic human right of free speech! Congratulations, you've taken the step that we would never dare to do!

Nickie.ua 

Jul 25, 2008

I can't believe some of you people actually think it's kinda cool to ban emo. I don't care much for emo, but surely one's style should be a matter of personal choice? If our gov't banned, say, heavy metal (which I totally bloody hate), I'd be the first to start listening to Slayer (check that, better yet Cannibal Corpse:). Ah well, maybe being from a former Soviet republic gives you a better perspective on such things. BTW, as far as I'm concerned, suicide should also be a matter of personal choice; trying to prevent people topping themselves by outlawing their lifestyle is akin to fighting the AIDS epidemic by banning condoms (on the assumption that this would scare people into celibacy). And all you people cheering for the Russians, I've got 2 things to ask you: a) are you as enthusiastic about the fact that 50% (!) of MODERN-DAY Russians named Stalin as the greatest Russian ever? and b) why do you bother reading the NME in the first place? I'd have thought http://www.faithalone.org/ would be more your thing.

Nickie.ua 

Jul 25, 2008

2 gillhaus? yes, it IS called the State Duma (Государственная дума, or Gosudarstvennaya Duma).

rich18786 

Jul 25, 2008

Even though mopey Emo's are annoying, they are harmless. They should be banning being a Chav!

BorstalBreakout 

Jul 25, 2008

A number of the posts on here are truly repugnant. I now have no doubt that fascism could flourish in this country. Lets's take them all to a remote shower block and gas them to death for having funny haircuts! Ha Ha! Look at the one with the stupid fringe gasping for air!I am not an emo myself, in fact I find so-called emo music to be rather tame and dull. However, we are all different and if someone else enjoys it, then good luck to them.If I had a kid, I would much rather they were listening to emo that the majority of the manufactured bilge and limp-wristed, bed-wetting dross NME seems to love.Expressions of emotion and creativity should be encouraged, not mocked by neanderthals too stupid to understand them.

chimpypete 

Jul 25, 2008

my sister's an emo. alas, if we lived in russia we could finally take her out into the yard and have her head shaved.

zebras54 

Jul 26, 2008

Whatever you think of emo, such legislation would limit the freedom of Russian teenagers. The example of what's going on n Krasnoyarsk, Siberia, is worrying and indeed the protesters are right by saying: "A Totalitarian State Encourages Stupidity". and I also agree with the slogan: ""Expressing psychological emotions is not forbidden by law." because if the regime is worried about people discussing and expressing emotions then logically they can ban theatre, literature, classical music as well. I don't see why emo is emotionally worse than Swan Lake or any classical story where there is death and/or suicide.

beckyboo432 

Jul 26, 2008

the laws are ridiculous really. another form of prejudice. i mean, i'm not an emo myself, and quite frankly i despise the culture (lol), but i don't think it's right to officially ban it. yes, there are these so-called "negative" aspects of emo culture - but emo-ness also encourages freedom of speech and expression and also creativity. i think the government has taken a step too far this time.

The Goddes 

Jul 28, 2008

the russian government can do nothing except ban something.why the government have to determine the country listen to what. or what the people don't listen?this thing prove russia is really a socialis country. the russian government made a law just because a child dead?.the people in russia have rights to listen emo and the government better not limit their people's rights

gone_insane 

Jul 28, 2008

I honestly dont even know what to say to this...That is like trying to ban cheese because it can give you nightmares which'll apparently cause you to murder people or something...This is pathetic! How can the government try and stop you from being who you are? If you are emo, FINE be emo. But half the time its not emo kids that actually cause the problems like self-harm because self-harm is always a private thing unlike the few stupid kids that will flash it on display and make it harder for people who actually do have problems to come out about them. I know this because I self-harmed for 9 years and I could never tell anyone due to the fact everyone would bully me further and I'd lose friends over it.There are better ways of solving the problems like suicide and self-harm, and thats called not being a judgemental idiot like the rest of the world. By judging others and putting them into groups we make things so much harder for ourselves. The whole world just continues to fall into an endless blooming mess due to the fact no-one can just accept the problems and try to work them out logically.The Russian Government are obviously alot more stupid than we all thought but then I can't say much coz the government in general is bloody stupid.

Bekka_10192 

Jul 30, 2008

HAHA! I burst out laughing when i heard about this. well im going over to russia soon. if someone asks you "do you have an crimial record?" you can say yeah for been emo! they`d just ...laugh in your face! And by the way. just because you dress emo/goth doesnt make you suicidal, people have problems,everyone does but some people feel like selfharm releases the angry,pain and that. the "law" Should really think this through. Fucking Stupid this like.

sxpxf 

Jul 31, 2008

I'm no fan of "emo", in fact I can't stand it. But why should they ban a genre of music that expresses many emotions a lot of kids can't get out themselves. The govt should be banning things like naked men/women on tv when kids are still watching it. How can you tell a child that it is OK to be having sex at 13 years old, but tell another that they can't listen to music that speaks about how they feel?? That's so incredibly rediculous and shows us where the world stands morally. it's screwed up!!!!

hecatemorana 

Jul 31, 2008

Wow, is all i really have to say. Look im gothic and wiccan. I dislike emo's because of the fact that they are grouped in with us. The "Emotional Goth" or emo as they are called for short were said to our brethren, when honestly they are nothing like us. Sure they dress dark, and the music that is considered emo i listen to as well. But they aren't us! And thats what pissed me off about them. But you cant put a legal censorship on a lifestyle choice! That isn't right, at all! Next they'll want to put a ban on being gothic, or jeeze they might wanna start up the ol' salem witch trials again. All that will happen is that you will have many rebellious people with a chip on their shoulder. And now you have actually given them one!!! Taking away a right is wrong and if some of them are deeply depressed then they will take it to the suicidal step. For they will feel like a prisoner in their own country, add that with anger and misguided thoughts...and BAM you have a suicide people.Being different shouldn't be a crime. Being suicidal should be. You cant prevent them from taking their own lives just cause they've changed their apperance...thats stupid thinking. But you cant just stand by and do nothing as well. But do a survey, find out how many really want to die. Find out why they dress the way they do.Because if being different is a crime, then you should lock me, the rest of the goths, the vampyres, the demons, the witches, and the liycans up as well. For we're in the same boat. and if given the choice i'd reather sink then swim.

jaideiris 

Aug 1, 2008

What I think is really messed up is that they all assume that if you wear black or listen to a rock genre then you might be likely to become suicidal? So if you wear colorful and a certain style clothing that means you're less likely to commit suicide? There have been instances where popular kids involved in sports and with high grades have committed suicide because they couldn't tell anyone how they feel. To ban dress style and music is a result of pure ignorance and stupidity. I for one hardly have any clothes that aren't black so (if I was in Russia) I should start buying clothes I don't like? Might as well walk around with nothing on then. The people they are targeting that are actually suicidal would, in my opinion, be more likely to commit the very action they were trying to prevent. Personally, if someone tryed to take away my freedom of expression I would be one very miserable person. But to connect a style of dress to biases is sickening. According to the government I OBVIOUSLY am a cutter because I have piercings, my hair partially in my face and OH MY GOSH wear black. I have never cut myself, I am not a "whiney moaning person" and I have listened to MCR before. But please do, lock me up then. I think Hitler would give this a thumbs up.

screamo 

Aug 4, 2008

this is f****** rediculous. Emo is not whats making the kids kill themselves, sh**** A*** governments r whats killing them.

Freedom_Freak 

Aug 4, 2008

I agree strongly with jaideiris. Emo is a way of form and freedom to those who choose to express it. You cant ban emo. If you do then ur taking away peoples choice of right and freedom of will. If your gonna do that then u might as well ban everything else cause not all emos are suicidial. Even a regular happy go-lucky person can become suicidial. You should never judge by the way a person looks. Cause everything is not what they seem. I wear all black and love listening to MCR and bands like that. You shouldnt make people be something theyre not because you dont like it. By what youre doing, you may be causeing the very act youre trying to prevent. Besides, being suicidial and being emo or goth or whatever is the person whos doing it, their choice. Its called Freedom of choice and freeom of rights. To the law of russia whos making this illegal, you are all ignorant and stupid to committing these acts. If people are committing suicide and protesting, its because of the law and those who are making it. i have so much more to say but this is all Im gonna write. So I say Go Protesters!

Richieboon 

Aug 5, 2008

If any of you thick emos actually took time to read the article rather than just the headline and suddenly leap up in a angst ridden tear tantrum then you might have realised they don't intend to ban it completely, only in school and government buildings. Is that such a bad thing?, and come on when was the last time you saw an emo in a government building.

Tobee 

Aug 7, 2008

ok, so i supposedly qualify as an emo, based on their definition.... and I know a fair amount of others that fit it too... and we all smile, we're all happy people! maybe its just because here i have freedom of expression, but i don't like being labeled as depressed and suicidal because of the way i dress... government buildings i can understand, a total respect thing as far as piercings go, i take mine out for work, no big deal. for all those that don't like emos, if you don't like it, don't look at me! but we accept the rest of you even tho your not like us, so be decent and do the same! point is, there are plenty of non-emos, that are suicidal, and depressed, and in most cases, even if you make it illegal to dress in that style, those kids will still probably be depressed, your not getting rid of the problem, just hiding it. If you want to fix it, actually solve the problem, don't just cover it up!!

zac123e 

Aug 11, 2008

ok u cant makeing a style illegal thats bull shit. teens should be able to be who they want to be.

Grim and Frostbitten 

Aug 11, 2008

Human rights much???Even if it is only in govenment buildings and schools its still wrong. Why emos and not spice boys/ moshers or w/eI've got nothing against any social stereotype, and I think anyone who has needs to sort themselves out.I'm disgusted by the way people have laughed at this, it highlights the ignorance and intolerance still present today.

teenage-filth 

Aug 11, 2008

This is rediculous. Being and 'emo' myself i have to say that dressing in mainly black, having your hair covering your face and having piercings does not make you want to kill yourself. It's dictatorship that's all! I don't self f***ing harm. Russia needs to realise that the only way of fixing this problem is by listening to these teenagers that are depressed and encouraging them to speak about their problems. Also if that law was made here i'd keep dressing in the same s**t as i do now so i assume Russian kids will too. Why does the government not care!? All they want is everyone to conform to what the deam as acceptable!

Richieboon 

Aug 11, 2008

Really hate to break the news like this, but emo is just a phase. can't say Iv'e seen to many guys in makeup strolling around the streets in there 20s+, oh wait, there called transvestites.

mcr_x123 

Aug 13, 2008

OMG that is a total pile of crap!people shuld be able to express their emotions!!xx

EMOwolf 

Sep 9, 2008

WTF! how can you BAN a music/fasion?that's not ok....that actually sucks. im banned from russia.

GoSquareGo 

Sep 19, 2008

you cant ban a trend or a music genre why not ban chavs

MCR_FOREVER 

Oct 2, 2008

What a load of shit. You can't ban a genre of music. Thats just like banning horror movies! Completely poynterless.

damned-for-life 

Oct 6, 2008

wtf!!!! me myself and I are not an emo but i feel so strongly about discrimination against them!to every ingnorant, idiotic and sensless person out there: not all emos self harm! alot actualy do smile! its just clothing and music people! no one seems to think about what the 'emo' culture thinks them! i see chav nd sporty and 'normal' peeps walk around in there 'in style' clothes and i wonder who do they think they're fooling! emos, goths, grungers ect hav the strength and courage to listen to what they want and dress in watevr they like! unlike normies who follow the crowd. these thoughts of the russian government are cowardly and will just creat more havock in our already war stricken world. freedom to be yourself tastes so sweet! i guess the russians dont like sweets n chocolate cause they are being incredibly bitter!

jerram 

Oct 28, 2008

I dont see those Hipocritical governments banning the alleged crimeful "chav" culture. They break into house's, underage drinking, they are purebread criminals, but no we can't charge them, they're only disgruntled youth!You know what, You can kiss my ass, it's not a crime to express emotion! belive it or not idiots, everyday people commit suicide and the majority of them are not emo!This law will not follow through, and if it does, their will be war.

~LuLu~ 

Nov 11, 2008

This is soo outrageous!!! it's pathetic!! it's prejudice!! Great, im band in russia, What will be next!? Huh ?We are not dangerous, and we are certainly not causing disruption and trouble in society! if anyone is, then think about those violent chavs! who want to hurt people just because they don't like how they look or what music hey listen to or, even for no reason.This is one of the most stupidest and most horrible thing i have ever heard! why can't people just respect eachother nomatter what they look like?! Why can't we just have peace everywhere! is it much to ask for? so if ur thinking of banning emo's u can get f***** because noone deserves this! don't u think theres bigger things to worry about like global warming n all that. How can you ban what u call a "culture"? i mean, nobody exactly follows people, wee all have our own unique styles, so you may steriotyppe us n believe we are harmful, but thats your loss, it's just sad that you'll never know the meaning of emo, and i feel sorry for you!

someday 

Nov 11, 2008

My 11 year old decided to become emo so she can "be herself." She wrote out a checklist of stuff she had to do in order to be an individual. 1. dress in black 2. dye hair black 3. comb hair over her face 4. act sadThat is why nobody wants this crap around. Self pity is a cancer of the soul. Some people just have it... but most people learn it. I make my living as an artist. Not only do I believe in self expression, I live it. I'm sorry to break it to you.. but Emo, Goth, Punk, is not self expression. There is NO self expression in FOLLOWING.With that said. It is a fad that everyone involved in will outgrow and It should not be banned... just laughed at.

MCR_FOREVER 

Nov 17, 2008

your 11 year old obviously doesn't really know how to truly express yourself, does she? You can't make a list of how to do it, it's just being yourself. She has probably just heard that is was cool, at school, or something. Being emo, goth, mosher etc. is not something that you just follow, like high street fashion, it is a genre and style of its own.

Littleblackcherry 

Nov 24, 2008

It always surprises me - how can you ban a subculture - throw to prison anyone wearing skinny jeans or having black hair? A little bit of common sense never did any harm. I think you cannot blame listenning to Emo music or wearing Emo style clothes for feeling depressed or down. There's much more to it, whole culture, look, style, which I love, and you can't just put all Emo's in one box and pretend the case is closed. I am relatively close to this subculture and write articles on http://www.littleblackcherry.co.uk - it's better to know more about the culture then just ban it blind-folded

three of hearts 

Dec 2, 2008

lolwut... about time

Add your comment

NME Alerts

Get NME news delivered direct to your desktop. Find out more

This Week's Issue
  • NME Magazine - The ultimate guide to the week in music
  • The ultimate guide to the week in music
  • NME Magazine - Subscribe now and save up to £45!
Please sign in

Forgot your password?

Register with MyNME

Every Tuesday and Friday

  • Up-to-the-minute news stories
  • The best new music and free downloads
  • Video interviews, photo galleries, competitions and more
  • Album and track reviews for the week ahead
  • Essential gigs in your area